대메뉴 바로가기 본문 바로가기

보고서·자료

OECD 직업교육훈련 국제비교(Ⅱ)

International Comparison of Vocational Education and Training in OECD Countries(Ⅱ)
저자
조은상 김수원 옥준필
분류정보
기본연구(2008-27)
발행기관
한국직업능력개발원
발행일
2008.11.30
등록일
2008.11.30
빈도높은 키워드
전문(Full-text) 내 키워드를 추출하고 사용 빈도를 분석하여 제공합니다.
직업교육훈련OECD
요 약
제1장  서 론
 제1절  연구사업의 필요성 및 목적 1
 제2절  연구사업의 내용 및 방법 3
 제3절  연구의 범위 및 용어 정의 5
제2장  OECD의 한국 VET 방문내용
 제1절  OECD의 VET 정책연구 개요 7
 제2절  OECD 기초조사 방문(Fact-finding Visit) 8
   1. OECD 기초조사 방문의 목적 8
   2. OECD 기초조사 방문단 8
   3. 기초조사 방문의 주요 일정 9
   4. 기초조사 방문의 주요 내용 10
 제3절  OECD 주 방문(Main Visit) 12
   1. 주 방문의 목적 12
   2. OECD 주 방문단 13
   3. 주 방문의 주요 일정 14
   4. 주 방문의 주요 내용 15
제3장  한국의 OECD VET 보고내용
 제1절  Korea OECD VET Questionnaire 19
   1. 직업교육훈련의 주요 지표 20
   2. 교육 체제 개관(교육 체제 그림) 34
   3. 직업교육훈련 체계 장단점에 대한 종합 평가 35
   4. 학생, 프로그램, 노동시장 요구의 일치 노력 62
   5. 정보의 흐름: 학생과 제공자에 대한 신호로서 산출에 대한 근거 65
   6. 사회 파트너의 관계를 위한 메커니즘 69
   7. 공급의 질 - 교사 인력과 프로그램의 질 78
   8. 투자, 재정 그리고 인센티브 82
 제2절  OECD VET Questionnaire International Comparison 83
   1. Part Ⅰ- VET 프로그램의 식별(OECD VET 설문) 83
   2. Part II - 각 프로그램에 관한 정보의 수집(OECD VET 설문) 90
   3. Part Ⅲ - 기업주체 직무훈련의 자금제공(OECD VET 질문사항) 110
   4. Part Ⅳ - 특정 직무에 관한 경로 정보(OECD VET 질문사항) 110
제4장  OECD의 한국 VET 정책권고안
제5장  결론 및 추후 연구과제
SUMMARY 135
<부록 1> OECD General description of the project 141
<부록 2> OECD Fact-finding visit guidelines 143 
<부록 3> OECD Fact-finding visit 결과 153 
<부록 4> OECD Main visit guidelines 175
<부록 5> OECD Main visit issue paper 185
<부록 6> OECD Main visit 결과 189
<부록 7> Outline Korea VET review 219
<부록 8> Korea OECD VET Questionnaire 235
<부록 9> OECD Korea Questionnaire Background Paper 241
참고문헌 315
  첫째, 우리나라의 직업교육훈련 관련 자료를 제공하며 둘째, OECD에서 주관하는 직업교육훈련 관련 설문조사, 주제 리뷰(Thematic Review) 등을 통하여 정책 대안을 상호교환하며 셋째, 한국에서의 직업교육훈련 관련 현황 및 이슈 파악을 위한 기초조사 방문 및 주 방문시에 필요한 지원을 제공함으로써 관련 정보의 교류와 집적, 나아가 우리나라 정부가 고려할 수 있는 정책적 대안을 OECD와의 협의 및 상호작용을 통해 개발하고자 함을 목적으로 한다.
  This research dealt with a variety of different subjects such as, the system of VET, VET program, labor market, social parter mechanism, finance and etc, to help OECD VET team research on “Learning for Jobs: the OECD policy review of vocational education and training". In order to answer the very comprehensive and difficult questions regarding VET questions in Korea, researchers reviewed literature, held expert committee, and implemented fact-finding and main visit by OECD VET team. Through this process, the voices were collected and reflected in the policy recommendations of OECD. 
  Recommendation 1: Stronger industry involvement in decision making over VET
  Create an institutional framework(e.g. permanent bodies at sectoral/ regional/national level) which allows employers and trade unions to be represented and systematically consulted on issues related to VET (including curriculum, qualifications, work placements, definition of VET provision etc.). In addition all interested ministries (Min of Edu, Min of Labour, and others) should be involved.
  Comments for Recommendation 1: The general direction of this recommendation is correct. However, as to employer participation, more concrete methods for implementation such as guidelines for providing incentives for corporations are needed, 
  Recommendation 2: Development of good quality workplace training
  Encourage initiatives (including local innovations) of partnership between VET institutions and firms leading to good quality workplace training, support and promote successful examples as ‘best practice’. General standards should be developed on the content, organisation and oversight of workplace training (e.g. how the training should be conducted). They should be developed in cooperation with industry. (E.g. in some countries general occupational competencies to be acquired by students, and requirements for VET trainers are specified) 
  Comments for Recommendation 2: It is necessary to invite employer's participation by providing the employers with incentives so that good quality workplace training can be implemented in a more effective way. 
  Recommendation 3: Improving skills of VET teachers 
  Encourage potential candidates to the teaching profession to have relevant work experience prior to entering the job, thisis especially lacking in upper sec VET.  
  Require all VET institutions to ensure that VET teachers regularly update their skills in the vocational area (and acquire knowledge of prevailing technology and practice in firms). 
  Comments for Recommendation 3: It is important to emphasize and develop continuously the on-site practical capacity of VET teachers for the successful implementation of VET. 
  Recommendation 4: Qualifications and assessment procedures
  We recommend aligning of graduation degrees and licensing exams. This could be done by creating a single qualifications framework  linked to VET institutions with competence-based exit assessments carried out with the involvement of employers. The requirements of such assessments would be reflected in the curricula of VET institutions.
  Comments for Recommendation 4: In case of formal educational institution, it is difficult to align graduation degree with certification tests because general curriculum as well as vocational curriculum for certification is included. However, as for the vocational training institutions, some vocational high schools, and some departments/special programs of community colleges, it is possible to apply industry(employer and unions)-initiated national skills standards and VET curriculum so that the current VET curriculum and certification tests can be adapted to the on-site practices. 
<표 Ⅱ-1> 기초조사 방문(Fact-finding Visit)의 주요 일정․9
<표 Ⅱ-2> 주 방문(Main Visit)의 주요 일정․14
<표 Ⅲ-1> 각급 학교 개황․20
<표 Ⅲ-2> 진학률 변화․21
<표 Ⅲ-3> 계열별 전문계고 입학자수․21
<표 Ⅲ-4> 전문계고 졸업자의 진학률․22
<표 Ⅲ-5> 전문계 고등학생의 진학상황․22
<표 Ⅲ-6> 직업능력개발사업 참가 현황․23
<표 Ⅲ-7> 전문계 고교생의 가구특성과 진로선택․25
<표 Ⅲ-8> 전문계고 학생의 중도탈락률․25
<표 Ⅲ-9> 연도별․학교종류별 중도탈락률․26
<표 Ⅲ-10> 연도별․학교종류별 졸업률․26
<표 Ⅲ-11> 대졸 신규 채용인력의 능력 수준이 기업의 요구에 부합하는 정도․28
<표 Ⅲ-12> 과거와 비교해 볼 때 기업의 요구에 부합하지 못하는 정도․28
<표 Ⅲ-13> 대학교육 중 강화해야 할 내용(인사담당자)․29
<표 Ⅲ-14> 직업기초능력의 직업에서 중요도(인사담당자)․30
<표 Ⅲ-15> 진학률 및 취업률 추이․31
<표 Ⅲ-16> 교육단계별 직업교육기관 졸업자의 취업률․32
<표 Ⅲ-17> 학력별 직업과 전공의 일치도․32
<표 Ⅲ-18> 학력별 고용률․33
<표 Ⅲ-19> 학력별 임금․33
<표 Ⅲ-20> 전문계 고등학교에 대한 주요 운영지원사업․44
<표 Ⅲ-21> 학력별 채용 현황․47
<표 Ⅲ-22> 학력별 고용률․47
<표 Ⅲ-23> 학력별 실업률․48
<표 Ⅲ-24> 학력별 임금․48
<표 Ⅲ-25> 학력별 월급여 격차․49
<표 Ⅲ-26> 직무와 전공과의 관계․49
<표 Ⅲ-27> 전공의 직무유용성․50
<표 Ⅲ-28> 직무의 학력일치도․50
<표 Ⅲ-29> 전문대학 졸업자의 직무만족도․50
<표 Ⅲ-30> 대학교육이 향후 지향해야 할 방향․51
<표 Ⅲ-31> 대학교육 중 강화해야 할 내용(인사담당자)․52
<표 Ⅲ-32> 대졸 신규 채용인력의 능력 수준이 기업의 요구에 부합하는 정도․53
<표 Ⅲ-33> 기업 요구에 부합하지 못하는 정도가 확대된 이유․53
<표 Ⅲ-34> 채용 당시의 직업기초능력 수준․54
<표 Ⅲ-35> 과거 대졸 신규 채용인력과의 직업기초능력 수준 비교․55
<표 Ⅲ-36> 과거 대졸 신규 채용인력과의 직업기초능력 수준 비교․55
<표 Ⅲ-37> 직업교육훈련대상별 기업참여 메커니즘 현황과 최근 동향․71
<표 Ⅲ-38> 산업별인적자원개발협의체(Sector Council) 내용․73
 Ratio of vocational High School Students․246
Ratio of vocational High School Students by Program․247
Distribution of junior college students by Program․252
Training Courses of the Multi-skilled Technician Program․259
Curriculum at KCCI HRD Institute․263
Major Support Business for Vocational High School ․268
Industry's Employment Status․271
Employment Status Depending on Schooling․271
Employment Rates Depending on Schooling․272
Unemployment Rates Depending on Schooling․272
Wages Depending on Schooling․273
Monthly Wage Difference Depending on Schooling․273
Relationship between Duties and Majors․274
Degree of Usefulness of Majors on the Job․274
Degree of Agreement between Duties and Schooling․275
Junior College Graduates' Degree of Satisfaction with Duties․275
Areas of College Education to be Stressed(Personnel Managers)․276
How much the skills level of the new employees with a college degree satisfies company standards․278
Industry's Reeducation Period of the new Employees and the Costs․279
Background Information about Schools․286
Changes in Rates of Entering Higher-Level Schools․286
No. of Entrants to Vocational High Schools by Categories․287
Rates of Vocational High School Graduates' Going to College․287
Rates of Professional High School Graduates' Going to College․288
Participation Status in the Development of Vocational Skills․289
Vocational High School Students' Family Characteristics and their Decision on the Course after Graduation․290
Percentages of Vocational High School Students' Dropping out of School․292
Dropout Percentages in terms of Year and Types of Schools․292
Graduation Rates in terms of Year and Types of Schools․293
How much the skills level of the new employees with a college degree satisfies company standards․293
Compared with the past, how big the gap between the new employees' skills and company standards is․295
Areas of College Education To be Stressed(Personnel Managers)․296
Degree of Importance of Basic Job Skills on the Job(Personnel Managers)․298
Trends in Rates of Going to College and Getting Employed․299
Employment Rates of the Graduates from Vocational Education Institutions at Each Education Level․300
Degree of Agreement between Occupation and Major Depending on Schooling․300
Employment Rates Depending on Schooling․301
Wages Depending on Schooling․301
Employment Statistic Status of Higher Education Institutions Compared to the Year Before․302
Employment Status Depending on the Types of Occupations․303
Employment Status Depending on the Company Size․304
Employment Statistic Status of Higher Education Institutions Compared to the Year Before․304
Junior College and University Graduates' Employment Rates Depending on their Majors․305
Junior College Graduates' Performance Skills․306
Skills that Industry Expects from Junior College Graduates․307
Reasons for College Education More Failing to Match Industry's Demands․308
Directions for College Education in the Future․309
Degree of Discrepancy in Basic Job Skills(Personnel Managers)․310
Relationship between Functions and Majors․311
Usefulness of Majors in the Functions․312
Degree of Agreement between Functions and Schooling․313 [그림 Ⅲ-1] 한국의 학제․34
관련 주제 다른자료의 번호, 제목, 저자, 발행일, 발행기관, 첨부 ㅈ어보
번호 제목 저자 발행일 발행기관 첨부
관련 과제 정보전체 1
기본 OECD 직업교육훈련 국제비교(Ⅱ) 2008.01.01~2008.11.30 바로가기
보고서·자료 콘텐츠 문의처
홍보팀 · 044-415-3557